From Resolutions to Intentions: A Sustainable Approach to Mental Wellbeing

Struggling with New Year’s resolutions? Learn how shifting from rigid goals to psychological intentions can support mental wellbeing, habit change, and self-compassion all year round.

---

The start of a new year often brings a surge of optimism. New planners, fresh habits, and ambitious goals promise change and growth. Many people resolve to be healthier, work harder, or finally break a bad habit. Yet research consistently shows that most New Year’s resolutions are abandoned within weeks.

The issue is rarely motivation or willpower. More often, it is the unrealistic expectations and rigid rules that underpin traditional resolutions. When change is framed as all-or-nothing, even small setbacks can feel like failure.

Rather than pressing “restart” on 1 January, a more sustainable approach is to view this time as a gentle psychological reset. Instead of dramatic transformation, we can focus on intentions — flexible, values-based guides for how we want to live, feel, and respond.

This article explores why resolutions often fail, how intentions support mental health, and practical, evidence-informed ways to create habits that last through journaling, mindfulness, and self-compassion.

---

Why New Year’s Resolutions Often Fail

Traditional resolutions are appealing because they promise a clean slate. Psychologically, however, they often set people up for disappointment.

They are too rigid. Goals such as “I will exercise five times a week” leave little room for illness, stress, or life interruptions. Missing one session can feel like failure.

They are outcome-focused. Targets like weight loss or savings totals focus on the end result rather than the daily behaviours that create change.

They reinforce perfectionism. One slip can trigger an “I’ve ruined it” mindset, leading many people to abandon their goal altogether.

This all-or-nothing thinking is linked to increased guilt, shame, and self-criticism — patterns that undermine motivation and mental wellbeing over time.

---

The Power of Psychological Intentions

Intentions differ from resolutions in both structure and mindset. They are values-driven, flexible, and process-oriented.

For example:

• Resolution: “I will run three times a week.”
• Intention: “I intend to move my body in ways that support my wellbeing.”

The intention allows for multiple expressions — walking, stretching, swimming, or resting when needed. It adapts to real life rather than demanding perfection.

Psychological intentions align closely with mental health principles. They encourage reflection, reduce self-judgement, and support consistency through compassion rather than pressure.

---

Habit Formation: Small Steps Create Lasting Change

Research into behaviour change consistently shows that small, repeatable actions are more effective than large, dramatic goals. Behaviour scientist BJ Fogg describes this as the power of “tiny habits” — behaviours that are so manageable they feel achievable even on difficult days.

Examples include:

• After brushing my teeth, I will write down one thing I am grateful for.
• When I make my morning tea, I will take three slow breaths.

Over time, these small actions compound. Instead of overhauling your life, you are building supportive routines gradually and sustainably.

---

Journaling for Clarity and Self-Awareness

Journaling is one of the most accessible tools for setting and maintaining intentions. Writing supports emotional processing, self-reflection, and awareness of patterns in mood and behaviour.

You do not need lengthy prompts or large amounts of time. A few minutes is enough.

Helpful approaches include:

• Intention journaling: Begin the day with “Today, I intend to…”
• Gratitude journaling: Note three things you appreciate, however small.
• Weekly reflection: Ask what energised you, what drained you, and what you want to adjust.

Research suggests journaling can reduce stress, improve emotional regulation, and enhance psychological insight — all essential for long-term wellbeing.

---

Mindfulness: Presence Over Perfection

Mindfulness is the practice of paying attention to the present moment without judgement. It is not about achieving constant calm, but about noticing thoughts, feelings, and sensations with curiosity.

As an intention, mindfulness might look like:

• Pausing before responding to a message or email.
• Eating one meal without screens, noticing taste and texture.
• Doing a brief body scan before sleep to release tension.

Mindfulness has been linked to reduced stress, improved focus, and greater emotional resilience. It also supports habit change by helping people notice automatic patterns and choose more supportive responses.

---

Self-Compassion: The Foundation of Sustainable Change

Self-compassion is often overlooked, yet it is one of the strongest predictors of lasting behaviour change. Contrary to popular belief, self-criticism does not motivate — it increases shame and avoidance.

Psychologist Kristin Neff identifies three core components of self-compassion:

• Self-kindness: Responding to yourself with understanding rather than judgement.
• Common humanity: Remembering that struggle is part of being human.
• Mindfulness: Acknowledging difficulty without exaggeration or avoidance.

In practice, self-compassion might involve reframing setbacks as learning opportunities, allowing rest without guilt, or asking, “What would I say to a friend in this situation?”

---

How to Set Psychological Intentions

A gentle, structured approach can help intentions feel meaningful rather than overwhelming:

1. Reflect on values. Consider what truly matters to you — connection, health, growth, balance.
2. Choose small, flexible actions. Start with behaviours that feel achievable.
3. Anchor to routines. Link intentions to habits you already have.
4. Track gently. Notice progress without rigid monitoring.
5. Reframe setbacks. View lapses as information, not failure.
6. Celebrate small wins. Acknowledge effort as well as outcome.

---

A Reset, Not a Restart

Personal growth does not come from wiping the slate clean or holding yourself to impossible standards. It is built in everyday moments — small pauses, mindful choices, and compassionate resets when things do not go to plan.

By focusing on intentions rather than resolutions, you support your mental health throughout the year, not just in January. Intentions invite presence, flexibility, and self-trust — qualities that make change sustainable.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Are intentions better than goals for mental health?
Intentions support mental health by focusing on values and process rather than perfection or outcomes. Goals can still be useful, but intentions provide flexibility and reduce self-criticism.

Can intentions still help with productivity or behaviour change?
Yes. Intentions guide behaviour in a way that adapts to changing circumstances, making consistency more likely over time.

What if I forget my intentions?
This is normal. Forgetting is not failure — it is an opportunity to gently reset and return to what matters.

Is this approach helpful if I struggle with anxiety or burnout?
Yes. Intentions, mindfulness, and self-compassion are commonly used in evidence-based therapies for anxiety, stress, and burnout.

---

When to Seek Professional Support

If you find yourself repeatedly stuck in cycles of self-criticism, burnout, or unhelpful habits, working with a psychologist can help. Therapy can support you to clarify values, build sustainable routines, and develop kinder ways of relating to yourself.

At CBT Professionals, our psychologists support adults with stress, anxiety, burnout, and behaviour change using evidence-based approaches such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based strategies.

Ready to take the next step?
Book an appointment with one of our psychologists to explore personalised support for your mental wellbeing.